A Guide to Sydney Courts and Tribunals -img

A Guide to Sydney Courts and Tribunals

Sydney’s judicial landscape boasts a myriad of courts and tribunals, each catering to specific legal matters and jurisdictions. This guide by Empower Wills & Estate Lawyers offers a concise overview of these institutions, helping you navigate the complexities of Sydney’s legal framework with ease.

Children’s Court of New South Wales

The Children’s Court of New South Wales is a specialised court that focuses primarily on matters involving children and young people. Its core purpose is to ensure that the best interests of children and young individuals are prioritised, and it operates under the principle that the welfare and well-being of the child are paramount.

Cases Handled: The court’s jurisdiction encompasses:

  • Care and Protection Matters: These involve cases where it’s alleged that a child or young person is at risk of significant harm and may need to be placed under the care of the state.
  • Criminal Matters: Addressing offences allegedly committed by children and young individuals (those aged between 10 and 18 years at the time of the alleged offence).
  • Compulsory schooling orders: Ensuring that children attend school as required by law.
  • Applications for Apprehended Violence Orders (AVOs): In situations where the defendant is a child.

Areas of Law Addressed:

  • Child Protection Law: Addressing the safety, welfare, and well-being of children and ensuring they are protected from harm.
  • Juvenile Justice: Laws specifically pertaining to the actions and treatment of young offenders.
  • Family Law: Especially as it pertains to the care and protection of children.

The Children’s Court of New South Wales plays a critical role in ensuring the protection and rights of children and young individuals within the state. With its specialised approach, it aims to address issues concerning children in a manner that recognises their vulnerability and unique needs.

District Court of NSW

The District Court of New South Wales is an intermediate court in the judicial hierarchy of the state. It sits between the Local Court and the Supreme Court of NSW in terms of its jurisdiction and authority. The District Court is one of the largest trial courts in Australia and handles a significant portion of the state’s serious criminal and civil cases.

Cases Handled:

  • Criminal Matters:
    • The District Court deals with a wide range of serious criminal offences, excluding murder and serious assaults. This includes cases like armed robbery, serious assaults, sexual assaults, large-scale fraud, and drug offences.
    • It is responsible for hearing appeals from the Local Court.
  • Civil Matters:
    • The District Court has jurisdiction to hear civil disputes with a claim value up to $750,000, though it can also deal with claims above this amount if parties consent.
    • It handles cases related to motor accidents, personal injuries, commercial and contract disputes, and more.

Areas of Law Addressed: The District Court addresses various areas of law, predominantly:

  • Criminal law: Ensuring that the principles of justice are adhered to and delivering judgments in serious criminal matters.
  • Civil law: Addressing disputes between individuals or organisations, determining liability, and awarding damages or specific remedies.

In addition to its primary functions, the District Court also plays a role in case management, ensuring that disputes are dealt with in a timely and efficient manner, minimising costs for all parties involved.

Dust Diseases Tribunal of NSW

The Dust Diseases Tribunal of New South Wales was established to provide expedited and specialised consideration of claims brought by individuals affected by dust-related conditions. Recognising the often aggressive nature of these diseases, such as asbestosis and mesothelioma, and the urgency with which cases need to be heard, the Tribunal provides a streamlined approach to ensure timely and fair resolutions.

Cases Handled: The Tribunal primarily deals with claims relating to:

  • Diseases caused by exposure to asbestos, such as mesothelioma, asbestosis, lung cancer, and pleural plaques.
  • Other dust-related conditions, which might arise from exposure to silica, mixed dust, or other harmful dust.
  • Compensation claims against manufacturers, suppliers, or employers responsible for the exposure.

Areas of Law Addressed:

  • Tort Law: Given that many of the claims deal with negligence, liability, and duty of care, the Tribunal often addresses matters within tort law, determining if there was a breach of duty that led to the plaintiff’s condition.
  • Compensation Law: This relates to the monetary compensation awarded to victims for their illnesses, taking into account factors like pain and suffering, medical expenses, loss of earnings, and more.

The Dust Diseases Tribunal of NSW operates under its own legislation, the “Dust Diseases Tribunal Act 1989”. It’s worth noting that the Tribunal’s jurisdiction is exclusive, meaning no other court in NSW can determine a claim for damages arising from a dust disease. This specialisation ensures a high degree of expertise in handling these sensitive and complex cases.

Drug Court of New South Wales

The Drug Court of New South Wales is a specialised court established to help offenders with drug dependencies break the cycle of drug use and criminal activity. The main purpose of the court is to divert offenders from the traditional criminal justice system and provide them with supervised rehabilitation programs. It offers an alternative to imprisonment for drug-dependent offenders.

Cases Handled: The Drug Court deals with individuals who:

  • Are charged with drug-related offences or where drug addiction is a significant factor in the offence.
  • Are likely to be sentenced to full-time imprisonment if convicted.
  • Voluntarily agree to participate in the Drug Court program.

It’s important to note that certain serious offences, including violent or sexual offences, are excluded from the Drug Court’s jurisdiction.

Areas of Law Addressed:

  • Criminal Law: Specifically related to drug offences or crimes committed under the influence or for the benefit of drug habits.
  • Rehabilitative Justice: The court takes a restorative and rehabilitative approach, emphasising treatment and recovery rather than punitive measures.

The Drug Court’s primary focus is on treating the underlying cause of drug-related criminal behaviour, with the goal of reducing reoffending and improving the overall health and well-being of participants. It involves a collaborative approach that includes judicial supervision, mandatory drug testing, and participation in treatment programs. The Drug Court of New South Wales represents an innovative approach to addressing the complex intersection of drug dependence and criminal behaviour.

Land and Environment Court of NSW

The Land and Environment Court of New South Wales is a specialist court that deals with environmental, planning, and land matters. Established in 1980, the court’s objective is to ensure that decisions impacting the environment and land usage in New South Wales are just, legally sound, and sustainable.

Cases Handled: The Land and Environment Court’s jurisdiction encompasses a variety of matters including:

  • Environmental and Planning Cases: This covers development applications, planning instruments, and environmental impact assessments.
  • Land Cases: These relate to land valuations, compulsory acquisitions, and title disputes.
  • Civil Enforcement: The court handles environmental offences such as pollution, illegal land clearing, and breaches of planning or development controls.
  • Criminal Jurisdiction: The court deals with prosecutions for breaches of planning, environmental, and protection laws.
  • Mining Matters: It adjudicates disputes arising from mining applications and activities.

Areas of Law Addressed:

  • Environmental Law: This includes legislation designed to protect the environment and ensure sustainable land and resource use.
  • Planning Law: Laws related to the regulation and management of development and the use of land.
  • Land Law: This encompasses laws related to land ownership, usage, and disputes.
  • Mining Law: It pertains to the extraction of minerals and resources and their associated rights and regulations.

The Land and Environment Court plays a critical role in balancing the need for development and progress with the imperative to protect and sustain the natural environment, cultural heritage, and community welfare in New South Wales. The court ensures that stakeholders, including community members, developers, and government agencies, have a platform to address and resolve their land and environment-related disputes in a fair and comprehensive manner.

NSW Local Court

The NSW Local Court is the first level of the New South Wales judicial system. Its primary function is to handle the majority of civil and criminal matters in the state in a timely, efficient, and accessible manner. It is designed to manage less complex disputes so that higher courts can focus on cases that require more extensive judicial attention.

Cases Handled:

  • Criminal Cases: The Local Court handles the majority of minor criminal cases, known as summary offences. These might include minor thefts, traffic infringements, and minor assaults. It also conducts committal proceedings to determine whether more serious criminal cases, known as indictable offences, should proceed to the District or Supreme Court.
  • Civil Cases: The court deals with civil disputes where the claim is up to $100,000 (though there are some exceptions). This could include matters like minor debt recovery, small claims, and some personal injury cases.
  • Apprehended Violence Orders (AVOs): The court manages applications for Apprehended Domestic Violence Orders and Apprehended Personal Violence Orders.

Areas of Law Addressed:

  • Criminal Law: The Local Court addresses less serious criminal offences but plays a crucial role in the early stages of serious criminal matters through committal proceedings.
  • Civil Law: The court addresses disputes between individuals or entities over rights, obligations, and liabilities.
  • Family and Domestic Violence Law: Through its management of AVOs, the court addresses issues relating to personal safety and protection from violence or harassment.

The NSW Local Court plays a fundamental role in the state’s justice system. Its widespread presence across New South Wales ensures that residents have local access to justice, particularly for more straightforward matters, without the need for the extensive processes of higher courts. The court is pivotal in ensuring the broader judicial system remains uncluttered and can operate efficiently.

NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal

The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal, commonly referred to as NCAT, was established to consolidate the specialist tribunal processes in New South Wales into one entry point. Its main purpose is to provide a one-stop-shop for efficient and accessible dispute resolution in a range of civil disputes and administrative matters.

Cases Handled:

  • Administrative Review: NCAT reviews decisions made by New South Wales government agencies, including licensing decisions, freedom of information requests, and decisions related to various professions.
  • Guardianship Division: This division makes decisions concerning the appointment of guardians or financial managers for adults who lack the capacity to make their own decisions.
  • Occupational Division: This division has jurisdiction to handle professional discipline matters for a variety of professions, including health practitioners, legal professionals, and real estate agents, among others.
  • Consumer and Commercial Division: It handles a wide range of consumer disputes, including residential tenancy issues, home building disputes, motor vehicle claims, and retail lease disputes.

Areas of Law Addressed:

  • Administrative Law: Through its administrative review functions, NCAT addresses decisions made by NSW government agencies to ensure fairness, legality, and appropriateness.
  • Guardianship Law: The Tribunal deals with matters related to the protection and decision-making capacity of vulnerable adults.
  • Occupational and Professional Discipline: The Tribunal oversees the conduct of various professionals, ensuring they adhere to standards and can take action if they breach professional norms or standards.
  • Consumer and Commercial Law: NCAT plays a vital role in resolving disputes in areas such as tenancy, building contracts, and various consumer complaints.

The NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal offers a more streamlined, efficient, and generally less formal alternative to court proceedings. Its broad jurisdiction ensures that residents of New South Wales have an accessible venue to resolve many of the everyday disputes they might encounter.

State Coroner’s Court of NSW

The State Coroner’s Court of New South Wales has the primary role of overseeing investigations into certain deaths, fires, and explosions to ensure that they are thoroughly examined. The Court aims to clarify the causes and circumstances of these events and, where possible, to provide recommendations or comments that could prevent similar occurrences in the future.

Cases Handled: The State Coroner’s Court investigates:

  • Reportable Deaths: These include, but aren’t limited to, deaths that are unexpected or result from an accident or injury, deaths in custody or as a result of police operations, and deaths where the identity of the deceased is unknown.
  • Fire and Explosions: Investigations aim to determine the origin and cause of fires and explosions, especially those that result in significant property damage, injury, or loss of life.
  • Disasters: In some circumstances, the Coroner may also examine disasters or multiple fatalities that are of particular public concern.

Areas of Law Addressed:

  • Coronial Law: The primary area of law addressed by the State Coroner’s Court is Coronial Law, which involves legal principles and procedures relevant to death investigations. This can include the examination of medical, forensic, and sometimes criminal aspects surrounding the event.
  • Public Health and Safety: The recommendations and comments that emerge from the court’s investigations often address issues of public health, safety regulations, and protocols, aiming to prevent future occurrences of similar events.

The State Coroner’s Court plays an essential role in the justice system of New South Wales by ensuring transparency and accountability in investigations of particular deaths and significant incidents. It provides a necessary function in bringing closure to families and making recommendations that safeguard the well-being of the community.

Supreme Court of NSW

The Supreme Court of New South Wales is the highest state court in the New South Wales judicial system. Its primary purpose is to hear and determine complex civil and serious criminal matters, as well as appeals from decisions made in lower courts within the state. It also has supervisory jurisdiction over all subordinate courts and tribunals in NSW, ensuring that justice is administered fairly across the state.

Cases Handled: The Supreme Court’s jurisdiction encompasses:

  • Civil Cases: Especially those that involve large sums of money or complex legal issues, such as equity matters, probate, and administration matters.
  • Criminal Cases: The Court’s criminal jurisdiction is limited to the most serious offences, such as murder, treason, and major drug offences.
  • Appeals: The Court of Appeal and the Court of Criminal Appeal, both divisions within the Supreme Court, hear appeals from decisions made in the District Court, other lower courts, and tribunals in NSW.

Areas of Law Addressed:

  • Civil Law: Including contract disputes, torts, equity, trusts, and property law.
  • Criminal Law: Addressing major criminal offences under state legislation.
  • Administrative and Constitutional Law: The court can review administrative decisions and rule on constitutional matters pertaining to the state.
  • Probate and Succession: Including the validation of wills and administration of deceased estates.

The Supreme Court of NSW is an integral part of the state’s judicial framework. As the highest court in the state, it sets critical legal precedents, upholds the rule of law, and ensures that justice is served with fairness and integrity. Empower Wills & Estate Lawyers represents their clients in will contesting cases in the Supreme Court of NSW. 

About The Author

Oliver Morrisey
Oliver Morrisey

Oliver Morrisey LL.M lives and breathes succession law.

Oliver is the Founder and Director of Empower Wills and Estate Lawyers, a law practice specialising in will and estate disputes. Oliver prides himself on the business providing the following customer-centric promises:

1. developing a professional client relationship built on trust.
2. achieving the best outcome for the client.
3. delivering quality services to the client efficiently and effectively.

Located in Edgecliff in Sydney's Eastern Suburbs, Oliver travels regularly to visit clients who choose him for his extensive knowledge and experience.

Oliver invites partnerships or referral enquiries.

Join Our FREE Monthly Newsletter to receive

10% Off Our Services*

* Secure discount now and use it later. Discount applies to solicitor fees only for the life of a matter up to a maximum of $5,000 benefit.

Sign up here